Shallow depth of field

Posted on by

Home › Forums › Camera › Shallow depth of field

  • Creator
    Topic
  • #215380
    IgorVe
    Participant

      Dear Sir Roger Deakins,

      Just curious about your opinion, knowledge and taste regarding the shallow DOF that seems overused in the popular cinema today. It was always called “cinematic” because until the early 2010s, only really large projects could get access to the technology. But now it’s used even where not determined by logic to emphasize something. Isn’t it a sort of “cheat code” to make DP’s and Director’s life easier, because it’s much more complicate to create a mise-en-scène where everything is in sharper focus?

      Asking not only because it’s my opinion, but also after being impressed by your still photography style:

      which is more into classic Bresson/Brassai/Koudelka philosophy.

       

      Can’t even imagine a still from you like this:

       

      Of course, we cannot compare still photography and cinema in the way the of telling a story and can’t beat physics when the POI is close to the lens, but isn’t it enough amount of blur? Isn’t it that “cinematic” whatever that means:

      What’s a reason to make it more blurry like in 90% of modern films? Or does it mostly come from Directors and Producers? And what’s so special in Batman’s look for you? Because it’s completely the opposite of what you’re doing and looks like unnatural CG for unexperienced eye.

      Please sorry for a long question and poor English as well. Thanks for the site and knowledge!

    Viewing 16 replies (of 16 total)
    • Author
      Replies
    • #260133

      Personally i value most understanding the intention. I love Shallow depth of field as well as tilt shift as well as a large depth of field. What it glues together is intention imo. If there is a a consistency and intention to the choice of the photographer and if it looks good i do not mind at all. And i like minimalisic images i think, shallow depth of field is often the cheap way out to tidy up a scene if the backgrounds are too distracting or too busy. That makes a large DOF often a luxury and when everything still comes together it also looks fantastic. But the Zero optics used on rebel moon omg tehy look so beautiful. I also built a anamorfake 50mm 1.1 with the oval insert of what would be a 3x anamorphic and i just love how it looks.

      My Website

      recent work:
      Link1
      Link2
      Link3

    Viewing 16 replies (of 16 total)
    • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.